I have now completed my review of this book. My thanks to Wipf and Stock for sending me a review copy. Of course I write as an interested amateur, not a professional scholar, so my opinions are those of an educated layman.
The review may be found here (PDF):
That was a very thorough and interesting review. I can see why it took time.
Thank you! It seemed unreasonable to do less, and one could have done more. Interesting to see, all the same.
Outstanding review. I don’t need to slog through the volume now.
You are very evenhanded, although an anti-secreter, as am I.
I do get the impression that some of the pro Secreters tend to sort of nitpick and whine. Cough, Scott Brown, cough. Reddit gaggle, cough, cough.
I did finally read the Quesnell article, on JSTOR. It is outstanding.