Earlier today I discussed the appearance of the word “gladiatrix” in the oldest scholia on Juvenal. I had hoped to find the passage in an online manuscript, but I didn’t have any good source for the manuscripts of the scholia.
Soon afterwards a kind gentleman then sent me a copy of Wessner’s 1931 edition of the Scholia in Iuvenalem Vetustiora. Before I looked at the manuscripts, I started to read the ancient biography of Juvenal at the front.
Then I looked at the first scholion, which is attached to the very first words of Satire 1. At the start I noted the use of “eo quod”, so familiar in the Vulgate for “because”:
Semper ego… Iuvenalem aliqui Gallum propter corporis magnitudinem, aliqui Aquinatem dicunt. ea tempora Domitiani tyranni, quibus etiam ipse vixit, eo quod in aula ipsius plus histriones quam bonae vitae homines possent, graviter carpsit. Hos autem libros in exilium missus ad civitatem ultimam Aegypti Hoasim ab ipso Domitiano scripsit. Ideo autem in exilium missus est, quia dixit versum illum (VII 90] quod non dant proceres, dabit histrio.
Some say that Juvenal was a Gaul, on account of the size of his body, others a native of Aquino. In the time of the tyrant Domitian, in which also he lived, he was a violent satirist, because in his palace actors were of more influence than men of good life. But he wrote those books in exile having been sent to the furthest city of Egypt, the [Great] Oasis, by this Domitian. But for this reason he was sent into exile, because he uttered that verse, “what the nobles do not give, the actor will.”
No wonder the scholia have been attributed to the same period as the Vulgate! The mention of the Oasis, later to be the place of exile of Nestorius, again suggests a late date.
Then I looked at the table of manuscripts.
Wessner indicates various sources in the manuscripts for the scholia. One of these he simply describes, uselessly, as:
Fragmenta Aroviensia (Q), quae nunc in archio urbis Aroviae (‘Aarau’) asservantur, oIim pertinebant ad codicem Iuvenalis s. X scriptum….
Q is in fact his main source for the portion of the scholia which mentions “gladiatrix”. I wondered if it was online. Wessner’s description is not helpful. But Aarau turns out to be a German-speaking Swiss town. In Braund &c, A Companion to Persius and Juvenal, here, we find a list of principal manuscripts of Juvenal. “Arou. (Q in Wessner) is the library given as “Aarau, Stadtarchiv I, Nr. 0”.  It is described as “Fragmenta Aroviensia” and consists of 5 leaves reused for bindings, one of which happens to be a section of the 6th Satire.
But sadly it does not appear to be online. Nor was the Montpellier manuscript, once the property of Pierre Pithou, and originally from Lorsch, which also is important.
Nice to know that we are in the right place! On page 53, we see the heading of satire 2, De philosophis obscenis, On foul philosophers.
Our reference to “gladiatrix” is to be found on page 134, on line 6:
Also interesting to see the Greek transcribed at the end!
Some may ask how I located the passage in the manuscript. What I did was to have Wessner’s edition open, in a searchable PDF. I then picked a random page, looked for a word that wasn’t “est” or something trivial, and searched for it in the PDF. A few clicks soon indicated where in the text I was. The word itself would not be unique; but looking at the word after would help. Once I knew where I was, I could move forward or back in the online manuscript, as seemed desirable; and repeat. I ended up aiming for halfway through – Satire 6 is about halfway through – and then moving back.
Nice to see “gladiatrix” in a manuscript written in the 900s AD!
- Reading “carpsit” as “he was a satirist”, because of the sense of tearing at reputation; and “multum/plus posse”, “to have much/more influence”.↩
- Update Jan. 2021: This is indeed the reference. A correspondent wrote to the archives in Aarau (website here) and got the reply: “Das Juvenal-Fragment befindet sich im Stadtarchiv Aarau, I Nr. 0, vgl.: Katalog der mittelalterlichen Handschriften des Klosters Wettingen ; Katalog der mittelalterlichen Handschriften in Aarau, Laufenburg, Lenzburg, Rheinfelden und Zofingen, S. 195f.”↩