Rod Letchford has written to say that he has compiled a list of links to all the volumes of the Patrologia Latina available online. It’s here:
http://cyprianproject.info/PL.htm
Apparently they all work from where he is, in Australia.
Thoughts on Antiquity, Patristics, putting things online, information access, and more
Rod Letchford has written to say that he has compiled a list of links to all the volumes of the Patrologia Latina available online. It’s here:
http://cyprianproject.info/PL.htm
Apparently they all work from where he is, in Australia.
Stephen C. Carlson kindly points out here that some of the GCS Greek texts have been transcribed and are available for free download here. I’ve translated the German:
Starting with vol. 7 NF (= Daniel-Kommentar des Hippolyt) a selection of reading texts from the editions in the GCS series is available for free download.
Release of the material is generally carried out at the same time as the release of the volume. Some other types of documents are also here, which are otherwise not available and complement our selection.
To read the file (PDF format) on your screen or print them, you need “Acrobat Reader” which can be found on the Internet free of charge.
Suggestions would be gratefully received.
Anonyme Kirchengeschichte (Gelasius Cyzicenus) = 1,1 MB (PDF)
Daniel-Kommentar Hippolyts = 501 KB (PDF)
Handschriften-Register zu Albert Ehrhard = 768 KB (PDF)
Martyrium Clementis = 1,35 MB (PDF)
Miraculum Clementis – Codex Parisinus graecus 1510 (D) = 44 KB (PDF)
This is truly excellent news, and the GCS are to be commended very highly indeed. Nor is this all; for there is more about the Hippolytus material here.
For an online presentation of the GCS the Daniel commentary of Hippolytus (GCS NF 7) was chosen and partly indexed.
The data processing of the Greek text and the translation from the Church Slavonic, each with their own apparatus, has been conducted by Arnd Rattmann (GCS). He was also responsible for decyphering the difficult manuscript originals of Marcel Richard († 1976), which led to the new edition of the text of Bonwetsch.
We would like to thank the publisher Walter de Gruyter for permission to place the works fully on the Internet. We should point out that the book may be ordered from the publisher. This contains the detailed indexes and other valuable information for usage of the text.
We should emphasize that we are dealing in this project of the month with a trial. We are grateful for suggestions and comments and positive feedback.
We should definitely give them feedback and encouragement! But … anyone got any ideas how?
UPDATE: I’ve found some email addresses here. The transcriber, Arnd Rattmann, is one of them. There’s a whole section for the GCS. I have buzzed an email at three people.
Tom Schmidt writes to say that he has started a translation of the Commentary on Daniel by Hippolytus, which he mentions here.
Fragments of the work appear in the ANF collection, but a nearly complete Old Slavonic version exists (used by the Sources Chretiennes) and likewise a Greek version, which was published by GCS. So this will be the first complete English translation.
Fr. Stefan Zara’s site used to contain a list of the volumes of the CSEL in Google Books. Unfortunately it has just been shut down. It was hosted by WordPress who understandably took exception to some of the material that he was sharing. I think that some was copyright in the US if not in his native Romania. I thought I would add his banner at the left here, so we can remember it.
However I found a cached version of this useful list from 8 October 2009 in Google cache. To preserve this useful item, I have edited it down and post it here. Please add further links in the comments, if you come across them. I don’t maintain collections of links, you see, as I have so much else to do.
The Corpus Scriptorum Ecclesiasticorum Latinorum (CSEL) is a series of critical editions of the Latin Church Fathers published by a committee of the Austrian Academy of Sciences.
The CSEL is intended to include the ecclesiastical authors who wrote in Latin from the late 2nd century AD until the death of Bede in 735. The texts are edited on the basis of all extant manuscripts and according to the principles of modern textual criticism and thus aim to provide a critical replacement for the corresponding volumes of the Patrologia Latina.
Vol. 1 | SULPICIUS SEVERUS, Opera – ed. C. Halm 1866; PSEUDO-SULPICIUS SEVERUS, Epistulae – ed. C. Halm 1866 |
Vol. 2 | FIRMICUS MATERNUS, De errore profanarum religionum – ed. C. Halm 1869; MINUCIUS FELIX – ed. C. Halm 1867 |
Vol. 3.1, 3.2, 3.3 | CYPRIANUS, Opera – ed. W. Hartel 1868/71 |
Vol. 4 | ARNOBIUS, Adversus nationes – ed. A. Reifferscheid 1875 |
Vol. 5 | OROSIUS, Historiae adversus paganos, Apologeticus – ed. C. Zangemeister 1882 |
Vol. 6 | ENNODIUS, Opera – ed. W. Hartel 1882 |
Vol. 7 | VICTOR VITENSIS, Historia persecutionis Africanae provinciae, PSEUDO-VICTOR VITENSIS, Passio septem monachorum, Notitia provinciarum et civitatum Africae – ed. M. Petschenig 1881 |
Vol. 8 | SALVIANUS, De gubernatione dei, Epistulae, Ad ecclesiam – ed. F. Pauly 1883 |
Vol. 9/1 | EUGIPPIUS, Epistula ad Probam virginem, Vita S. Severini – ed. P. Knöll 1885 |
Vol. 9/2 | EUGIPPIUS, Excerpta ex operibus S. Augustini – ed. P. Knöll 1886 |
Vol. 10 | SEDULIUS, Carmen paschale, Opus paschale, Epistulae – ed. J. Huemer 1885; editio altera supplementis aucta – cur. V. Panagl 2007 |
Vol. 11 | CLAUDIANUS MAMERTUS, De statu animae, Epistula ad Sapaudum – ed. A. Engelbrecht 1885 |
Vol. 12 | AUGUSTINUS, Speculum, Liber de divinis scripturis – ed. F. Weihrich 1887 |
Vol. 13 | Iohannes CASSIANUS, Conlationes – ed. M. Petschenig 1886; editio altera supplementis aucta – cur. G. Kreuz 2004 |
Vol. 14 | LUCIFER CALARITANUS, De non conveniendo cum haereticis, De regibus apostaticis, De sancto Athanasio, De non parcendo in deum delinquentibus, Moriendum esse pro dei filio, Epistulae – ed. W. Hartel 1886 |
Vol. 15 | COMMODIANUS, Carmen apologeticum, Instructiones – ed. B. Dombart 1887 |
Vol. 16/1 | Poetae Christiani Minores: PAULINUS PETRICORDIAE, Carmina – ed. M. Petschenig; ORIENTIUS, Carmina – ed. R. Ellis; PAULINUS PELLAEUS, Eucharisticos – ed. W. Brandes; CLAUDIUS MARIUS VICTOR, Alethia – ed. C. Schenkl; PROBA, Cento – ed. C. Schenkl; ANONYMUS, Sancti Paulini epigramma, Versus ad gratiam domini, De verbi incarnatione, De ecclesia – ed. C. Schenkl; 1888 |
Vol. 17 | Iohannes CASSIANUS, De institutis coenobiorum et de octo principalium vitiorum remediis, De incarnatione Domini contra Nestorium – ed. M. Petschenig 1888; editio altera supplementis aucta – cur. G. Kreuz 2004 |
Vol.18 | OROSIUS, Commonitorium de errore Priscillianistarum et Origenistarum – ed. G. Schepss 1889 |
Vol. 18 | PRISCILLIANUS, Tractatus, Canones – ed. G. Schepss 1889 |
Vol. 19 | LACTANTIUS, Divinae institutiones, Epitome divinarum institutionum – ed. S. Brandt 1890 |
Vol. 20 | TERTULLIANUS, De spectaculis, De idololatria, Ad nationes, De testimonio animae, Scorpiace, De oratione, De baptismo, De ieiunio, De anima, De pudicitia – ed. A. Reifferscheid, G. Wissowa 1890 |
Vol. 21 | FAUSTUS REIENSIS, Opera – ed. A. Engelbrecht 1891 |
Vol. 22 | HILARIUS PICTAVIENSIS, Tractatus super psalmos – ed. A. Zingerle 1891 |
Vol. 23 | ANONYMUS, (Cypriani) Carmen ad quendam senatorem – ed. R. Peiper 1881 |
Vol. 23 | CYPRIANUS GALLUS, Heptateuchos, Fragmenta, De Sodoma, De Iona propheta; PSEUDO-HILARIUS, In Genesin ad Leonem papam, De martyrio Maccabaeorum, De evangelio – ed. R. Peiper 1891 |
Vol. 24 (bound with 23) | IUVENCUS, Evangeliorum libri – ed. J. Huemer 1891 |
Vol. 25/1, 25/2 | AUGUSTINUS, De utilitate credendi, De duabus animabus, Contra Fortunatum Manichaeum, Contra Adimantum, Contra epistulam fundamenti, Contra Faustum Manichaeum, Contra Felicem Manichaeum, De natura boni, Epistula Secundini, Contra Secundinum Manichaeum – ed. J. Zycha 1891/92 |
Vol. 26 | OPTATUS MILEVITANUS, Contra Parmenianum Donatistam, Appendix decem monumentorum veterum – ed. C. Ziwsa 1893 |
Vol. 27/1 | LACTANTIUS, De opificio dei, De ira dei, Carmina, Fragmenta – ed. S. Brandt 1893 |
Vol. 27/2.1 , 27/2.2 2 | LACTANTIUS, De mortibus persecutorum – ed. S. Brandt, G. Laubmann 1897 |
Vol. 28/1 | AUGUSTINUS, De Genesi ad litteram liber imperfectus, De Genesi ad litteram, Locutiones in Heptateuchum – ed. J. Zycha 1894 |
Vol. 28/3 | AUGUSTINUS, Quaestiones in Heptateuchum, Adnotationes in Iob – ed. J. Zycha 1895 |
Vol. 29 | PAULINUS NOLANUS, Epistulae – ed. W. Hartel 1894; editio altera supplementis aucta – cur. M. Kamptner 1999 |
Vol. 30 | PAULINUS NOLANUS, Carmina; PAULINUS PELLAEUS, Oratio – ed. W. Hartel 1894; editio altera supplementis aucta – cur. M. Kamptner 1999 |
Vol. 31 | EUCHERIUS, Opera – ed. C. Wotke 1894 |
Vol. 32/1 32-1 Praefatio | AMBROSIUS, Hexameron, De paradiso, De Cain, De Noe, De Abraham, De Isaac, De bono mortis – ed. C. Schenkl 1896 |
Vol. 32/2 | AMBROSIUS, De Iacob, De Ioseph, De patriarchis, De fuga saeculi, De interpellatione Iob et David, De apologia prophetae David, De Helia, De Nabuthae, De Tobia – ed. C. Schenkl 1897 |
Vol. 32/4 | AMBROSIUS, Expositio evangelii secundum Lucam – ed. C. Schenkl 1902 |
Vol. 33 | AUGUSTINUS, Confessiones – ed. P. Knöll 1896 |
Vol. 34/1 | AUGUSTINUS, Epistulae 1-30 – ed. A. Goldbacher 1895 |
Vol. 34/2 | AUGUSTINUS, Epistulae 31-123 – ed. A. Goldbacher 1898 |
Vol. 35/1–2 | COLLECTIO AVELLANA, ed. O. Günther 1895, 1898 |
Vol. 36 | AUGUSTINUS, Retractationes – ed. P. Knöll 1902 |
Vol. 37 | CASSIODORUS, Contra Apionem – ed. C. Boysen 1898 |
Vol. 38 | FILASTRIUS, Diversarum hereseon liber – ed. F. Marx 1898 |
Vol. 39 | ITINERARIA HIEROSOLYMITANA – ed. P. Geyer 1898 |
Vol. 40/1–40/2 | AUGUSTINUS, De civitate Dei – ed. E. Hoffmann 1899/1900 |
Vol. 41 | AUGUSTINUS, De fide et symbolo, De fide et operibus, De agone christiano, De continentia, De bono coniugali, De virginitate, De bono viduitatis, De adulterinis coniugiis, De mendacio, Contra mendacium, De opere monachorum, De divinatione daemonum, De cura pro mortuis gerenda, De patientia – ed. J. Zycha 1900 |
Vol. 42 | AUGUSTINUS, De perfectione iustitiae hominis, De gestis Pelagii, De gratia Christi, De nuptiis et concupiscentia – ed. C. F. Vrba, J. Zycha 1902 |
Vol. 43 | AUGUSTINUS, De consensu evangelistarum – ed. F. Weihrich 1904 |
Vol. 44 | AUGUSTINUS, Epistulae 124-184 – ed. A. Goldbacher 1904 |
Vol. 45 | EVAGRIUS, Altercatio legis inter Simonem Iudaeum et Theophilum Christianum – ed. E. Bratke 1904 |
Vol. 46 | RUFINUS, Interpretatio orationum Gregorii Nazianzeni – ed. A. Engelbrecht 1910 |
Vol. 47 | TERTULLIANUS, De patientia, De carnis resurrectione, Adversus Hermogenem, Adversus Valentinianos, Adversus omnes haereses, Adversus Praxean, Adversus Marcionem – ed. E. Kroymann 1906 |
Vol. 48 | BOETHIUS, In Prophyrii isagogen commenta – ed. S. Brandt 1906 |
Vol. 49 | VICTORINUS PETAVIONENSIS, Opera – ed. J. Haussleiter 1916 |
Vol. 50 | [AMBROSIASTER] PSEUDO-AUGUSTINUS, Quaestiones veteris et novi testamenti – ed. A. Souter 1908 |
Vol. 51 | AUGUSTINUS, Psalmus contra partem Donati, Contra epistulam Parmeniani, De baptismo – ed. M. Petschenig 1908 |
Vol. 52 | AUGUSTINUS, Contra litteras Petiliani, Epistula ad catholicos de secta Donatistarum, Contra Cresconium grammaticum et Donatistam – ed. M. Petschenig 1909 |
Vol. 53 | AUGUSTINUS, De unico baptismo, Breviculus collationis cum Donatistis, Contra partem Donati post gesta, Sermo ad Caesariensis ecclesiae plebem, Gesta cum Emerito Donatistarum episcopo, Contra Gaudentium Donatistarum episcopum – ed. M. Petschenig 1910 |
Vol. 54 | HIERONYMUS, Epistulae 1-70 – ed. I. Hilberg 1910/1918; editio altera supplementis aucta 1996 |
Vol. 55 | HIERONYMUS, Epistulae 71-120 – ed. I. Hilberg 1910/1918; editio altera supplementis aucta 1996 |
Vol. 56/1 | HIERONYMUS, Epistulae 121-154 – ed. I. Hilberg 1910/1918; editio altera supplementis aucta 1996 |
Vol. 56/2 | HIERONYMUS, Epistularum Indices – comp. M. Kamptner 1996 |
Vol. 57 | AUGUSTINUS, Epistulae 185-270 – ed. A. Goldbacher 1911 |
Vol. 58 | AUGUSTINUS, Epistulae: Praefatio et indices – ed. A. Goldbacher 1923 |
Vol. 59 | HIERONYMUS, In Hieremiam prophetam – ed. S. Reiter 1913 |
Vol. 60 | AUGUSTINUS, De peccatorum meritis et remissione et de baptismo parvulorum, De spiritu et littera, De natura et gratia, De natura et origine animae, Contra duas epistulas Pelagianorum – ed. C. F. Vrba, J. Zycha 1913 |
Vol. 61 | PRUDENTIUS, Carmina – ed. J. Bergman 1926 |
Vol. 62 | AMBROSIUS, Expositio de psalmo CXVIII – ed. M. Petschenig 1913, editio altera supplementis aucta – cur. M. Zelzer 1999 |
Vol. 63 | AUGUSTINUS, Contra Academicos, De beata vita, De ordine – ed. P. Knöll 1922 |
Vol. 64 | AMBROSIUS, Explanatio super psalmos XII – ed. M. Petschenig 1919; editio altera supplementis aucta – cur. M. Zelzer 1999 |
Vol. 65 | HILARIUS PICTAVIENSIS, Tractatus mysteriorum, Fragmenta, Ad Constantium Imperatorem, Hymni; PSEUDO-HILARIUS, Epistula ad Abram filiam, Hymni – ed. A. Feder 1916 |
Vol. 66/1 | HEGESIPPUS, Historiae – ed. V. Ussani 1932 |
Vol. 66/2 | HEGESIPPUS, Historiae: Praefatio et indices – comp. C. Mras 1960 |
Vol. 67 | BOETHIUS, De consolatione philosophiae – ed. W. Weinberger 1934 |
Vol. 68 | GAUDENTIUS BRIXIENSIS, Tractatus – ed. A. Glück 1936 |
Vol. 69 | TERTULLIANUS, Apologeticum – ed. H. Hoppe 1939 |
Vol. 70 | TERTULLIANUS, De praescriptione haereticorum, De cultu feminarum, Ad uxorem, De exhortatione castitatis, De corona, De carne Christi, Adversus Iudaeos – ed. E. Kroymann 1942 |
Vol. 71 | CASSIODORUS, Historia tripartita – ed. W. Jacob, R. Hanslik 1952 |
Vol. 72 | ARATOR SUBDIACONUS, De actibus apostolorum (Historia apostolica) – ed. McKinlay 1951 |
Vol. 73 | AMBROSIUS, Explanatio symboli, De sacramentis, De mysteriis, De paenitentia, De excessu fratris Satyri, De obitu Valentiniani, De obitu Theodosii – ed. O. Faller 1955 |
Vol. 74 | AUGUSTINUS, De libero arbitrio – ed. W. M. Green 1956 |
Vol. 75 | BENEDICTUS NURSINUS, Regula – ed. R. Hanslik 1960 (editio altera et correcta 1977) |
Vol. 76 | TERTULLIANUS, Ad martyras, Ad Scapulam, De fuga in persecutione, De monogamia, De virginibus velandis, De pallio – ed. V. Bulhart 1957 |
Vol. 76 | TERTULLIANUS, De paenitentia – ed. Ph. Borleffs 1957 |
Vol. 77 | AUGUSTINUS, De magistro – ed. G. Weigel 1961 |
Vol. 77 | AUGUSTINUS, De vera religione – ed. W. M. Green 1961 |
Vol. 78 | AMBROSIUS, De fide ad Gratianum Augustum – ed. O. Faller 1962 |
Vol. 79 | AMBROSIUS, De spiritu sancto, De incarnationis dominicae sacramento – ed. O. Faller 1964 |
Vol. 80 | AUGUSTINUS, De doctrina christiana – ed. W. M. Green 1963 |
Vol. 81/1-3 | AMBROSIASTER, Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas – ed. H. J. Vogels |
Vol. 82/1-4 | AMBROSIUS, Epistulae et acta – ed. O. Faller, M. Zelzer 1968-1996 |
Vol. 83/1 | MARIUS VICTORINUS, Ad Candidum Arrianum, Adversus Arium, De homoousio recipiendo, Hymni – ed. P. Henry, P. Hadot 1971 |
Vol. 83/2 | MARIUS VICTORINUS, In epistulam Pauli ad Ephesios, In epistulam Pauli ad Galatas, In epistulam Pauli ad Philippenses – ed. F. Gori 1986 |
Vol. 84 | AUGUSTINUS, Expositio quarumdam propositionum ex epistula ad Romanos, Epistulae ad Galatas expositio, Epistulae ad Romanos inchoata expositio – ed. J. Divjak 1971 |
Vol. 85/1-2 | AUGUSTINUS, Contra secundam Iuliani responsionem opus imperfectum, lib. 1-3; 4-6 – ed. M. Zelzer 1974; 2004 |
Vol. 86 | RUFINUS, Basili regula – ed. K. Zelzer 1986 |
Vol. 87 | EUGIPPIUS, Regula – ed. F. Villegas, A. De Vogüé 1976 |
Vol. 88 | AUGUSTINUS, Epistulae nuper in lucem prolatae (Epistulae Divjak) – ed. J. Divjak 1981 |
Vol. 89 | AUGUSTINUS, Soliloquia, De inmortalitate animae, De quantitate animae – ed. W. Hörmann 1986 |
Vol. 90 | AUGUSTINUS, De moribus ecclesiae catholicae et de moribus Manichaeorum – ed. J. B. Bauer 1992 |
Vol. 91 | AUGUSTINUS, De Genesi contra Manichaeos – ed. D. Weber 1998 |
Vol. 92 | AUGUSTINUS, Contra sermonem Arrianorum (praecedit Sermo Arrianorum) – ed. M. J. Suda, De correptione et gratia – ed. G. Folliet 2000 |
Vol. 93/1 | AUGUSTINUS, Enarrationes in Psalmos 1-32 (expos.) – ed. C. Weidmann 2003 |
Vol. 94/1 | AUGUSTINUS, Enarrationes in Psalmos 51-60 (expos.) – ed. H. Müller 2004 |
Vol. 95/3 | AUGUSTINUS, Enarrationes in Psalmos 119-133 – ed. F. Gori 2001 |
Vol. 95/4 | AUGUSTINUS, Enarrationes in Psalmos 134-140 – ed. F. Gori adiuvante F. Recanatini 2002 |
Vol. 95/5 | AUGUSTINUS, Enarrationes in Psalmos 141-150 – ed. F. Gori adiuvante I. Spaccia 2005 |
Vol. 96 | ANONYMUS, In Iob commentarius – ed. K. B. Steinhauser adiuvantibus H. Müller et D. Weber 2006 |
UPDATE: Bob Buller very kindly sent me a bunch of extra links to fill the gaps on this, and I have added them in. Thank you!
UPDATE: A correspondent is sending me some corrections, which I am merging in.
UPDATE: More links here.
UPDATE: Thanks to Ted Janiszewski for some more!
I often find that these links get out of date pretty rapidly, so here is the latest one I have come across. The Ancient World Online links to the complete Patrologia Graeca in a pretty user-friendly downloadable pdf format. From the Library of Ruslan Khazarzar.
The PDF’s are not just images, but text.
NOTE: My collection of PDF’s of page images is here.
All done by Brigham Young University, and are here. At the moment I think there is a problem with some of the links, but this will be fixed.
Most of the books are liturgical etc, but there is a Syriac New Testament, another containing Paul’s letters, a collection of Isaac of Scete and Cyriacus of Antioch, a couple of works by Barhebraeus including the “Chronicle of the ages”, and a Garshuni version of the world history of Michael the Syrian. Some unclassified “collections of religious works” might bear investigation.
There is a very useful list of links to the ROC, with details of the Syriac materials in them, here. The volumes are all at Archive.org in complete form, and the scanning was sponsored by Gorgias Press, who thereby deserve our gratitude. I thought the list could usefully appear here also:
Because of an error in printing, some pages of this volume are out of order.
At the end of this volume there is an index of vols. 1-10.
An email from Jesus de Prado draws my attention to a new bunch of online books, which we all need to take a look at:
Contents: http://s2w.hbz-nrw.de/ulbbn/nav/classification/16431
Misc books: http://s2w.hbz-nrw.de/ulbbn/nav/classification/135030
Arabic Christian: http://s2w.hbz-nrw.de/ulbbn/nav/classification/16475
Armenian: http://s2w.hbz-nrw.de/ulbbn/nav/classification/17269
Coptic: http://s2w.hbz-nrw.de/ulbbn/nav/classification/17261
Ethiopic: http://s2w.hbz-nrw.de/ulbbn/nav/classification/17268
Georgian: http://s2w.hbz-nrw.de/ulbbn/nav/classification/17270
Syriac: http://s2w.hbz-nrw.de/ulbbn/nav/classification/17267
Full coloured-image, quite high resolution reproductions with full bibliographical details.
Thank you! Well, I had to go and look. The list of titles is quite impressive.
The interface is a bit clunky, but there are PDF’s to be had, although it looks as if each section is a PDF (which is a bit silly, and a nuisance; please fix this, chaps). In some cases they have placed a PDF of the lot on the left-hand side.
Design is a little weird. They seem to imagine — as librarians do — that you would want to use the books over a slow internet connection on a slow site, rather than on your PC. The interface is the usual, fussy, self-centered thing that library sites so often are, designed to maximise their traffic rather than assist the reader. Come on chaps; Google books and Archive.org show how it should be done. Why reinvent the wheel?
But these are small points. On to the good stuff!
The Arabic list contains a considerable quantity of really old books, 17th century, of great value. These belong to the first wave of European interest in Arabic studies. The 1661 Eutychius, for instance, is there.
The Armenian list includes a catalogue of the Mechitarist daughter monastery in Vienna. Aucher’s edition of Eusebius Chronicle is there — a year or two back I paid a serious sum for a photocopy of just volume 1!
The Coptic list includes a catalogue of the Borgia mss in the Vatican.
The Syriac list includes six volumes of Bedjan’s Acta martyrum et sanctorum. The Urmiah catalogue is there, which I have only seen so far in a rather rubbishy photocopy PDF. Mind you, they don’t seem to have learned the trick of photographing with a piece of black paper behind each page, to stop bleed-through of the text on the reverse. You can download the whole Urmiah catalogue.
This is probably the first sign of useful material from a German source that I have seen. More please!
A customer for my CDROM of the Fathers wrote to ask if I had a PDF of vol. 2 of Cyril’s Commentary on John, since I had scanned it for my site. Luckily for him I had the chance to look, and found the images first shot.
I’ve now uploaded a searchable PDF of this volume to Archive.org. It’s here:
http://www.archive.org/details/CyrilOfAlexandriaCommentaryOnJohnVolume2Tr.T.Randell
(Or will be in a few minutes)
This was the final volume in the Oxford Movement Library of the Fathers series of translations. The series began in 1838. By 1880 E.B.Pusey was dead, and the movement was history. Yet, somehow, this one last volume appeared, in 1885. It wasn’t published by Parker of Oxford, and it wasn’t edited by Pusey; but the title-page was uniform with it. The last few volumes were unnumbered.
By this time the Ante-Nicene Fathers series was 20 years old. Most collections of the Library of the Fathers were obsolete. Very few of them indeed ever acquired this last, final volume. I obtained this one through the courtesy of Glasgow University Library, who benevolently photocopied it and posted it to me. May their name be ever remembered; for I doubt any other copy of this very, very uncommon book, is ever likely to get scanned.
Volume 1 of the Commentary contained books 1-5. It was translated by Phillip E. Pusey, the crippled son of old Pusey, who predeceased his father. P.E.Pusey edited Cyril’s works, and his editions still have value. But as a translator he was useless, tending to transliterate the Greek. A vicious review, which I have never been able to locate, halted his efforts and he never proceeded further with Cyril on John. The otherwise unknown T. Randell did this volume, and made a nice job of it. It’s far easier to read than vol. 1! It covers books 6-12, although some of those books are lost and only catena fragments were available.
There’s quite a lot of Orthodox interest in this text. Let’s hope this helps make it more available.
PDF’s are such a blessing. I’ve been looking at the PDF of volume 1 of the Mingana collection of Syriac manuscripts in Birmingham. How quickly we take these for granted! Once, just to consult such a volume, would have meant a day off work, a 60 mile journey, and being robbed blind for copies — if I was even allowed copied. That was the situation, only five years ago. Not now!
This will be a dull post, I fear. Because I ordered some photos of manuscripts in the collection, but no longer remember what was so precious in them! This post is my journey of discovery.
On p.599 of the PDF (col. 1197 of the book), there is listed the various snippets of Eusebius in various manuscripts. In July 2008 I went through these, and ordered the following from the Mingana:
Ms. Mingana Syr. 332 Folios 1-9a Eusebius Ms. Mingana Syr. 480 Folios 29a-31b Eusebius Ms. Mingana Syr. 589 Folios 1-6a Eusebius
Time to refresh my memory on these!
First I’m opening the Mingana catalogue in Adobe Acrobat and running an OCR on the file to create scannable text. I only wish Adobe used some decent OCR software. Come on chaps, talk to Abbyy!
OK. On p. 308 of the PDF (col. 616) we find ms. 332. On ff.6b-7a there are quotations on the genealogy of Jesus, from Ephraim, Eusebius of Caesarea, and Philoxenus. Wonder why I ordered as far as 9a.
On p. 432 of the PDF (col. 863) is ms. 480. Ff. 29a-31b consist of tables to show that there is no contradiction between the two genealogies of Jesus in Matthew and Luke. The first table is from Severus of Antioch; the others from Ephraim, Eusebius and Philoxenus. Not sure why I thought this stuff was worthwhile, now.
On p. 562 of the PDF (col. 1125) is ms. 589.
Fascinating stuff… or not. This is what so manuscripts consist of, tho; pages of short, dubious-looking texts.
The upshot is that there is unlikely to be much here to impact on my Eusebius project. Wonder what the “short treatise on chronology is”? I might toss that over to my translator and ask.